interview by JANA LETONJA
Kris Polaha takes on one of the most intense roles of his career in American Hostage, a psychological crime thriller inspired by the extraordinary true story of a 1977 Indianapolis hostage crisis that unfolded live on the radio. He stars as mortgage company president Dick Hall, who is kidnapped by Tony Kiritsis and becomes the focus of a gripping public standoff driven by accusations of corporate greed and corruption. The series marks a darker turn for Kris, whose wide-ranging credits span Hallmark romances as well as Wonder Woman 1984, Jurassic World Dominion, Mad Men, The Good Doctor and Landman. American Hostage airs on Amazon MGM+, his film The Space Between is available on Angel.com and his Hallmark film Mistletoe and Mimosas airs on November 15.
photography by KAILEY SCHWERMAN
American Hostage is based on an extraordinary true story. How familiar were you with the Tony Kiritsis case before this project came your way?
I wasn’t familiar with this story at all. In fact, I was born 10 days after Dick Hall was taken captive by Tony Kiritsis.
What was your first reaction when you read the script and realized you’d be playing Dick Hall, the man literally caught at the center of this ordeal?
Honestly, upon first reading, I asked myself how I was going to make sitting in a chair with a gun tied to my neck interesting for 8 episodes. I knew my performance wasn’t going to be able to rely on words or great big physical actions, so I knew it would be a performance closer to mime or mask work. I knew that subtlety and listening, and staying present with razor sharp precision would be my only assets.
When you’re playing a real person in such extreme circumstances, where do you begin your research? How much were you able to learn about the real Dick Hall?
Dick Hall wrote a book titled Kiritsis and Me that he wrote 40 years after the events of February 8, 1977. Curiously, he never spoke about those 63 hours with his kids. He never did interviews or talked about it on record, so this book is the only information out there about the kidnapping aside from the 911 calls and the actual news footage of Kiritsis and Hall. That book is where I found all the information I needed to play Dick Hall.
Did you feel a particular responsibility knowing that these events happened to real people and that you’re dramatizing what must have been an incredibly traumatic experience?
Absolutely, I felt a huge responsibility to play Dick Hall with dignity and decency. I knew that Giovanni would sparkle as Tony and that the audience would be rooting for Tony, like people were in real life. I knew that my job was to create balance and create room for people to have sympathy for Dick too, to create equilibrium. His kids are alive, he has grandkids out there, and I wanted them to feel like I gave their grandaddy a fair shake.
The hostage situation famously unfolded live on the radio. What does that public element add psychologically for Dick, knowing that this terrifying private experience is simultaneously becoming a spectacle?
I’m not sure how aware Dick Hall was of the public spectacle aspect of his kidnapping until after it was all over. He and Tony were suddenly infamous. One night, Dick was in his kitchen drinking a beer and he looked over and saw himself drinking a beer on his television set because the nightly news camera crew was camped out in front of his house and broadcasting him live. The other crazy story that puts things into perspective is when Tony was acquitted, they announced it during a Colts football game and the entire stadium started cheering for Tony. Tony was the hero of the entire affair and that was extremely confusing for Dick.
Was there a particular scene or moment that you found especially difficult, either technically or emotionally, to film?
I think the scene that required the most grit was the dream sequence we filmed where Dick walks to his airplane in a snowy field. Adam Arkin was directing and we filmed outside during the coldest day on record in Winnipeg’s history. It was January 20 and the temp dropped to -32.6 C which is -26.6 F. It was colder in Winnipeg that day than it was at the North Pole. I didn’t have a hat or gloves on because it was a dream, and, man, was it cold. People can die from that kind of extreme cold in about 15 minuets.
Do you think audiences sometimes underestimate actors who work extensively in lighter genres? Was there something satisfying about getting the opportunity to show a very different side of yourself here?
I think audiences do underestimate actors who choose to work in lighter genres, but unfairly so. I am a populist artist, I want my work to be seen and to be seen by everybody. I want the stories I am a part of to reflect the struggles, tastes, and values of working-class folks who, in turn, use their hard-earned money to stream the shows I make or to buy a ticket to my movies. Those projects tend to be a lighter genre because after a hard day’s work, I think most people want to unwind with a story that makes them feel good and allows them a bit of escape from the realities of their lives. Yet, it is also a pleasure to stretch as a storyteller and I am always looking for opportunities to do so.
Looking back over your career, was there a particular role that changed the way the industry saw you, or, perhaps more importantly, changed the way you saw yourself as an actor?
The role I played in an independent film called Where Hope Grows was that role for me. I played a man named Calvin who was drinking himself to death and I went to a place as an actor that cut deep. It still hurts to watch that particular performance, but it’s certainly worth watching.
True-crime stories are hugely popular, but they also raise questions about turning real trauma into entertainment. Was that something you thought about while making this series?
I couldn’t stop thinking about the real people involved in this story. I still think about Dick Hall’s surviving family, even now as the show is airing. He has kids, grown with kids of their own, and a community of people who knew him. I think about doing right by those people. My first starring role was to play John F. Kennedy Jr. in a made for television movie called America’s Prince, and I felt a huge responsibility in playing John. You can’t muck it up.
If viewers who primarily know you from your lighter work watch American Hostage, what are you most excited, or perhaps most nervous, for them to see?
I’m excited for them to see my physical transformation, I gained 25 pounds for the role and thinned out my hair to capture the image of a man who was no longer trying to win anybody over with his looks or charm. A man who has settled into the deep rhythm of his life.
What keeps you busy on your days off from filming?
My kind and beautiful wife, Julianne, and our three joyful sons. They afford me a rich, full life and there’s never a dull moment in our home.